Research Shows That Taking Away Recess As A Form Of Punishment Doesn’t Work. However, Schools Continue To Do So.

Posted on

When no one in a second-grade class in Florida admitted to stealing money from a classmate, the teacher had the students walk laps during recess. When a first-grader in Kentucky failed to pay attention in class, he was forced to sit next to his instructor and watch his classmates play. Pupils in a Texas first grade class were forced to sit inside for recess after a few students misbehaved.

Pediatricians and child development specialists believe that recess is essential for children’s well-being in the midst of lengthy, regimented school days laden with scholastic expectations.

Many primary school students around the country have their recess removed on any given day for minor violations like not finishing their work, talking out of turn, or not following instructions. Even though much evidence shows the value of unstructured play for young children, the long-standing and widespread punishment practice in schools persists.

Receipt time has recently been a target for legislation. Recess has been taken away as a form of punishment in Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Oklahoma, and Minnesota during the last year.

These states would go farther than any other in the country to prohibit the practice if they are successful. Teachers may be limited in how they apply the punishment in 11 additional states and the District of Columbia as well as places like the Austin Independent School District in Texas and the New York City Department of Education; few have absolute prohibitions.

The practice is still legal in most states, and even in locations where it is prohibited, enforcement may be difficult to come by. Parental complaints abound, even in places where physical exercise and/or recess time are mandated. Discipline choices have been reduced and recess has been withheld by overworked teachers with no consequence.

According to the Hechinger Report, which interviewed 18 parents and students and gathered 60 additional examples from parents and teachers across the country through social media and public testimony, young students across the country have been deprived of recess time, even in states where there are no laws prohibiting it.

‘Is this legal?'” Maren Christenson Hofer, whose autistic son missed recess more than once in kindergarten, tells the Minneapolis Star Tribune. That’s when I started wondering: Has this guy ever been around children?”

Withholding recess is considered by disability rights activists and child development specialists to be a sort of “shadow discipline,” which refers to less formal sanctions that are seldom documented. Silent meals and letting students stand outside the classroom are two more approaches that are similar. Suspension and expulsion are other types of punishment that may be harmful to children, but they are publicly recorded and the data on them is available for parents and the public to see.

However, it’s difficult to tell who’s subjected to these penalties or which schools are more likely to use them due to the fact that shadow disciplinary techniques aren’t as well documented. A poll indicated that 86% of instructors in the United States have reduced or eliminated recess as a form of punishment for students who misbehave.

Receipts are being canceled for a variety of reasons. Students’ misbehavior may be tiring for instructors who work long hours and sometimes lack help in dealing with it. Direct orders are sometimes given from above. Student handbooks feature policies on recess detention in the majority of school districts around the country.

Experts argue that taking away recess might be a simple approach to convince certain students to cooperate.

According to Rebecca London, assistant professor of sociology at the University of California, Santa Cruz, and author of the book “Rethinking Recess,” “I don’t actually believe the teacher has the purpose of damaging children.” They use it as a threat since it’s the time that kids want most.”

Nevertheless, the practice’s dangers have been well-documented for some time. As the American Academy of Pediatrics put it in 2013, recess “should not be denied for punitive or academic purposes.” An important part of child development is playtime, the organization stated, calling it “crucial and indispensable.”

Rachel Davis, a mother in Midland, Texas, says her two children have been denied recess on a regular basis for the last four years. Instead of playing, kids have been forced to walk laps or remain inside to do their job.

Davis said, “It’s so pointless…. “Let them be children.”

Even while walking laps allows youngsters to participate in physical exercise, experts suggest that doing so is a bad experience for them.

Depriving children of their daily break might harm their connections with their instructors, their attitudes toward school, and their perceptions of their own value. The penalty is particularly evident to their classmates and stigmatizing for children, according to child development specialists.

When it comes to their desire to go to school, their commitment to the school and the advantages kids get from it, “that has potential implications,” says Children’s Minnesota CEO Dr. Marc Gorelick.

A “total and full collapse” occurred in September when Davis’ 8-year-old son returned to school after his recovery from Covid, according to Davis. In order to make up for the work he had missed, her son said that he was not permitted to attend any extracurricular activities or lessons that day, such as painting or physical education.

Davis screamed, “This is crazy.” Why do we have to battle for recess? Haven’t we given up enough of our child’s day?

Davis contacted her son’s elementary school principal, who agreed to let her kid attend recess and after-school activities. Nevertheless, in November of the following year, Davis received an email from her son’s teacher saying the final draft of her son’s writing assignment was “not final draft quality,” and that he would be staying in for part of his recess to rewrite it. Davis was outraged. ‘He’s not going to be staying in, and that’s not acceptable!’ she said in an email to me.

There is no official policy in the Midland Independent School District about denying students their daily recess, according to a spokesman. For primary school pupils, 30 minutes of physical exercise each day must include recess or physical education instruction, according to state law.

Efforts have been made in Texas to ensure that recess is protected by law. The Republican governor of Texas, Greg Abbott, rejected a bill in 2019 that would have mandated school districts to adopt a recess policy that covered both mandatory break time and withholding. While Abbott lauded the bill’s “noble intentions” in a statement at the time, he contended that it would have created “bureaucracy for the sake of bureaucracy.”

Austin Independent School District’s school board enacted a policy in 2016 that prevents teachers from denying students recess as a punishment since there is no state statute against it. When asked by The Hechinger Report in an interview or through social media, nine parents in the district said that their children had been punished for missing homework or misbehaving in the last several years because of the policy.

On the condition that her last name be suppressed out of fear of reprisal from Austin school authorities, Lisa, an Austin mom who spoke anonymously, claimed her first-grade son was given only a few minutes of recess a day some years ago. He informed his mother he had to walk laps outside the classroom when he didn’t bring his homework. This practice was widespread in his class.

Lisa objected, saying, “That’s not proper.” Their military status is unconfirmed. A new school in the same district where she claims recess is not denied has her kid.

Even though he recognized that the policy was not commonly conveyed or implemented, Austin, Texas, superintendent of schools Anthony Mays was astonished to learn that recess had been denied.

“We hope this is not a prevalent practice,” Mays said. That unstructured play time is important to us,” says the school.

Upon hearing from The Hechinger Report in early April, the district issued a note to primary principals reminding them that recess is mandatory for kids and instructing them to promptly notify all teachers and staff of the policy.

Recess time for children in Illinois is the most recent state to try to safeguard it. Students in kindergarten through fifth grade must get 30 minutes of unstructured recess each day under a rule passed in 2021. The bill also prevents schools from taking away recess as a disciplinary tactic, unlike comparable regulations in Arizona and Florida.

In the aftermath of the law’s passage in Illinois, one teacher took to Facebook to voice her displeasure. She referred to recess as her “detention” time for dealing with pupils who had not completed their assignments, had poor conduct, or needed to make up work. When she noted that recess couldn’t be taken away from the students, she said, “The kids have gotten on very quickly.” Even if the students misbehave, “it doesn’t matter” if they refuse to perform their job. “It’s irrelevant.”

To ensure that teachers are supported if they’re dealing with tough behaviors, experts argue that school systems must take responsibility. In addition, increased training in classroom management strategies might help reduce teacher turnover: Many instructors cite classroom management issues as the major reason for quitting their jobs.

Teacher Cara Holt, a professional learning expert with NWEA, a non-profit that focuses on assessment and teaching, says that schools need to redefine their approach to classroom management in the early grades. Holt remarked, “It doesn’t have to be about the repercussions as much as it is about educating them in that time. In other words, “instead of being punitive,” she says, make sure pupils know why regulations are in place.

Teachers who deny students recess may be doing it at their own peril. There is a lot of evidence that recess is a good thing: After recess, children are more focused and industrious, and their cognitive abilities improve. Free play promotes the development of social skills, communication abilities, and coping abilities such as persistence, stress management, and self-control in children. It has been shown that elementary school pupils are more attentive following a recess, according to school administrators.

London observed, “Play is how children learn.” Imagination, socialization, and physical exercise are all enhanced when children have the opportunity to play together in a safe environment.

When teachers are already crammed with academics and exam prep, these advantages may not be immediately apparent to them.

Recess isn’t something teachers are told to do as a strategy to improve classroom control, according to London. “Nothing about recess is taught to them.”

Children’s rights campaigners like Christenson Hofer have been instrumental in the passage of a statute prohibiting the removal of youngsters from recess in Minnesota. Simon, her 11-year-old son, claimed he felt “simply devastated” after he was denied playtime numerous times during kindergarten. “I’m not likely to make better choices,” he said, making the exercise useless. It didn’t make me feel any better.”

Recess has been used as a form of punishment in Minneapolis Public Schools for the last decade, according to the Hechinger Report, which talked to two more families in the district and evaluated eight additional cases of parents who said their children had been punished by losing recess.

Remy Fortuin, 15, recalls being sent to a special education classroom instead of playground in elementary school as an effort to settle him down when he was overstimulated. “It was a complete waste of time,” he said. When I think of the room, I get terrible recollections of it. His mother, Nikki Fortuin, reported that on the days he was detained inside during recess, he would rush out at pick-up time like he was in a panic.

All elementary school students are required to have at least 30 minutes of daily recess, according to Crystina Lugo-Beach, a media relations coordinator for Minneapolis Public Schools. “Excluding children from physical activity due to behavior is in violation of the district’s behavior standards,” she said. During an interview, Lugo-Beach said that reminders concerning the wellness policy are provided to school administrators on a regular basis. She said that the district was unable to verify the accusations that recess was being denied by the school.

A virtual meeting of the Minnesota House of Representatives’ education policy committee was held on a Friday morning in March to endorse legislation that would prohibit schools from delaying recess. Recess was taken away from him by his instructors because of something he didn’t remember doing, he told the committee.

“However, I am autistic. This means that my anxiousness had a role in it,” he concluded. “At school, I have a lot of anxiety. When I’m anxious, I’ve been known to say things I later regret. When my professors tell me to remain down, I find myself wanting to get up and go about.”

The measure was met with opposition.

Because of his misbehavior, I’m sure my grandson has had to remain inside and miss recess.” Rep. Sondra Erickson, a Republican and former teacher, said following testifying regarding the measure, “You know he got over it.” After losing the option to deny recess, she wondered what kind of control instructors would have over student misconduct in the classroom.

It was included to an upcoming education policy law in spite of criticism from Erickson and others, who argued that recess should be protected.

Christenson Hofer expects a good effect even if the ban does not pass.

As more parents feel emboldened to speak out about the practice of withholding recess and why it should be discontinued, she added. Having this discussion now is more vital than ever, even if we have to go back to it next year.